LAW, CULTURE AND LEGAL REALITY: CRITICAL THINKING (CRITICAL RATIONALISM) AS A CONDITION FOR THE SURVIVAL OF SOCIETIES IN THE MODERN WORLD

Author (s):Lytvynov O. M.

Work place:

Doctor of Sciences (Law), Associate Professor, Professor of the Department of Social and Humanitarian Disciplines, Luhansk State University of Internal Affairs named after E.O.Didorenko, Sievierodonetsk, Ukraine

Language: Ukrainian

Scientific Herald of Sivershchyna. Series: Law 2018 No 1(3):18-31

https://doi.org/10.32755/sjlaw.2018.01.018

Summary

The article is a summary and development of some methodological provisions of the general cultural concept of law, where critical thinking, as the most important practical aspect of critical rationalism for jurisprudence, is interpreted in its salutary role for societies. The main obstacles in the formation of legal states as societies organized on the basis of the equal rights of each person are the archetypes of the past (the cult of force, the dichotomy of “friend or foe” and the irrational functional inconsistency of spheres of activity), which in the 21st century becomes an expression of the criminal act typical for representatives of non-creative secondary cultures. An example of the political, legal and economic degradation of Argentina in the twentieth century is given as a possible parallel for modern Ukraine.

The author notes the special role of the principles of the Reformation (1. equality, 2. individual responsibility, 3. the cult of honest labor) for modern legal understanding and the formation of a legal reality based on the observance of human rights, which was the result of critical rational thinking and actions. He proves that critical thinking is an epistemological tool that allows one to overcome the limitation of thinking and actions caused by the archetypes of the past, which becomes a condition for the survival of societies in the modern world, since the law realizes the unity of morality and intellect (mind).

Key words: law, culture, legal reality, philosophy of law, critical thinking, critical rationalism, society.

 

REFERENCES

  1. Lytvynov, O.M. (2014), Pravo yak fenomen kultury: sproba filosofskoho osmyslennia, Yantar, Luhansk.
  2. Lytvynov, O.M. (2016), Pravo yak fenomen kultury, avtoref. dys. … d ra yuryd. Nauk, 12.00.12, Filosofiia prava, NIuU im. Yaroslava Mudroho, Kharkiv.
  3. Lytvynov, O.M. (2017), “Pro pravovyi oksiumoron (lohiko-hermenevtychni rozdumuvannia shchodo vyrazu “konflikt kultur”)”, Visnyk, Derzh. un-tu vnutr. sprav im. E. O. Didorenka, Vyp. 1 (77). pp. 11-18, Luhansk.
  4. Bystrytskyi, Ye. (1996), Fenomen ukrainskoi kultury: metodolohichni zasady osmyslennia, in Shynkaru, V. (Ed), Feniks, Kyiv.
  5. Aristotel, (1976), O dushe. Sochineniya, v 4 t, T. 1, Asmus, V.F. (Ed), Myisl, Moskva, pp. 369-450.
  6. Platon, (1971), Gosudarstvo. Sochineniya: v 3-h t, T. 3, Ch. 1., in Loseva, A.F. and Asmusa, V.F (Ed) Myisl, Moskva, pp. 89-454.
  7. Maksimov, S.I. ( 2002), Pravovaya realnost: opyit filosofskogo osmyisleniya, Pravo, Harkov.
  8. Lytvynov, O.M. (2002), “Shchob nablyzyty realnist pravovoho suspilstva (notatky na storinkakh doslidzhennia pro pravo yak pravovu realnist)”, Visnyk Luhansk. akademii vnutr. sprav MVS im. 10-richchia nezalezhnosti Ukrainy, No. 3. pp. 254-263.
  9. Lytvynov, O.M. (2017), Pravo yak fenomen kultury, dys. … d-ra yuryd. Nauk, 12.00.12, Filosofiia prava, LDUVS im. E. O. Didorenka, Luhansk..
  10. Popper, K.R. (2005), Otkryitoe obschestvo i ego vragi, translated by Sadovskogo, V.N., Nika-Tsentr, Kiev.
  11. Tyaglo, A.V. and Voropay, T.S. (1999), Kriticheskoe myishlenie: problema mirovogo obrazovaniya XXI veka, Un-t vnutr. del, Harkov.
  12. Lytvynov, O.M. (2013), “Shchodo podolannia prymityvizmu sotsiumu ratsionalnistiu myslennia: metodolohichni zauvazhennia proty pozytyvistiv ta vulharnykh materialistiv”, Visnyk Luhansk. derzh. un-tu vnutr. sprav im. E. O. Didorenka, No. 3. pp. 24-32.
  13. Litvinov, A.N. (2011), “O kategorijah kul’tury i kategorijah prava: opyt kriticheski-metodologicheskogo razmyshlenija”, Filosofija prava. No. 6 (49). pp. 18-22.
  14. Fergjuson, N. (2017), Voshozhdenie deneg. Finansovaja istorija mira, translated by Koljandra, A. and Fajbisovicha, I. AST: SORPUS, Moskva.
  15. Lytvynov, O.M. (2017),” Reformatsiia. Velyka ukrainska yurydychna entsyklopediia”, T. 2. Filosofiia prava, in Maksymov, S.I. (Ed), Pravo, Kharkiv. pp. 731-735.
  16. Bergson, A. (1994), Dva istochnika morali i religii, translated by Gofmana, A.B. Kanon, Moskva.
  17. Efimov, I.M. (1977), Svergnut’ vsjakoe igo. Povest’ o Dzhone Lilberne, Politizdat, Moskva.
  18. Spinoza, B. (1957), Bogoslovsko-politicheskij traktat. Izbrannye proizvedenija, v 2-h t., t. ІІ, translated by Lopatkina, M., Gos. izd-vo polit. lit., Moskva, pp. 5-284.
  19. Spinoza B. (1957), Jetika. Izbrannye proizvedenija: v 2-h t., t. І, translated by Ivancova, N.A., Gos. izd-vo polit. lit., Moskva. pp. 359-618.
  20. Lytvynov, O.M. (2007), “Narodzhennia nehatyv-paternalizmu: shchodo bidy, shcho nasuvaietsia na nashu krainu, abo pro pryntsypy navchannia po-ukrainsky”, Visnyk Dnipropetrovsk. nats. un-tu: Filosofiia. Sotsiolohiia. Politolohiia, No. 15, pp. 285-292.
  21. Lytvynov, O.M. (2010–2011), “Nehatyv-paternalizm” yak kharakterystyka derzhavnoho ladu Ukrainy: sproba kulturolohichno-pravovoi diahnostyky” Problemy filosofii prava. T. VIII–IX, pp. 306-314.
  22. Lytvynov, O.M. (2007), “Osvita v Ukraini yak sotsiokulturna fiktsiia, abo pro systemnu deformatsiiu kulturnykh smysliv”, Ukrainska osvita u svitovomu chasoprostori, materialy Druhoho mizhnar. Konhresu, Kn. 1, Ukrahentstvo informatsii ta druku «Rada», Kyiv, pp. 318–319.
  23. Lytvynov, O.M. (2010), “Koruptsiia yak kulturna tradytsiia: sproba filosofsko-pravovoho analizu protsesu kryminalizatsii svidomosti”, Visnyk Luhansk. derzh. un-tu vnutr. sprav im. E. O. Didorenka. Spets. Vypusk No. 8: Problemy vdoskonalennia zakonodavstva pro protydiiu vidmyvanniu zlochynnykh dokhodiv i koruptsii (Donbaski pravovi chytannia). Luhansk,. pp. 181-191.
  24. Montesk’e, Sh. (1955) O duhe zakonov. Izbrannye proizvedenija, Gos. izd-vo polit. lit., Moskva, pp. 159-734.
  25. Platon, (1990), Apologija Sokrata, t. 1, translated by, Solov’eva, M.S. and Loseva, A.F. (Ed), Moskva, Mysl’, pp. 70-96.

[collapse]
| Full text .pdf

©2024. Penitentiary academy of Ukraine